Judge Says Toms River BOE Gave Ritacco Complete Control
District re-releases statement from guilty plea.
As he outlined his sentence for the former schools superintendent who admitted to 12 years of corruption at Toms River Regional, Judge Joel Pisano decried the level of trust school board members gave Michael Ritacco over the years while he stole from the district.
Michael Ritacco had the complete trust of the Toms River Regional School Board, said Pisano as he sentencing to Ritacco to more than 11 years in prison, and the board members shouldn't have trusted him.
"As superintendent, Mr. Ritacco had authority over virtually all aspects of school district operations. He had virtually complete control — whether that was by specific granted authority by his contract or pursuant to state law or via what became the increased tacit approval by the members of the board of education," Pisano said at the Sept. 14 sentencing in Trenton.
"Suffice it to say that the sin of the members of the boards of education that Mr. Ritacco was to serve was basically that they trusted him," Pisano said.
Ritacco put the blame on himself, saying he betrayed the school board, who was trusting of him.
"My boards of education, who I had the great privilege of working with, their trust and confidence has been breached. They took more leaps of faith that allowed us to do things that a lot of us wouldn't even consider," Ritacco said. "The town fathers, we would do mutual projects...recreation... all these people were put under increased public scrutinty because of my bad decision making."
Toms River Regional Spokesperson Tammi Millar, who attended the sentencing, said a statement the board released through President Ed Gearity after Ritacco's guilty plea was released again after Ritacco's sentencing Friday. The statement focuses on what the district has done to move forward, but also addresses how the board felt betrayed by Ritacco.
"This activity was very much concealed from this Board of Education, as well as others. The Board never abdicated their responsibility. Those who have attended the public committee meetings can attest to the fact that the Board asks many questions and seeks justifications for administrative recommendations. As a high functioning Board should operate, by the time we get to the regular action meeting, the issues have been discussed and hashed out through the committee system, leaving the Board to vote on the recommendation. This is not rubber-stamping, as recommendations have previously been fully vetted through the Board committee process and through addressing board member questions and concerns," said Gearity in the statement.
It continues: "As a board we feel betrayed by the former Superintendent, and the entire community was betrayed by the former Superintendent. What happened here was not a failure of the system, it was a failure of an individual and a violation of the trust imparted to him, both statutorily and in practice, by the very nature of his position."
In their own statement, three members of the board of education said the district still needs to increase transparency and better oversee the school's business. Board members Ben Giovine, Loreen Torrone and Alex Pavliv called for further reform.
The three members, elected in 2011, said they were disappointed some of the reforms suggested in the previous year lacked the majority of board votes to pass.
Giovine said he hoped many of the initiatives would change the culture of Toms River Regional to allow for more open school government.
The votes that failed included creating a personnel committee and televising board meetings. The switch to put the school budget to school board vote and not to the public voters on a ballot was also disappointing, the three said.
“We must clean up the culture that let this occur," Giovine said. "There must be renewed transparency in the district’s budgeting and personnel decisions.”
Pisano said it was problematic that Ritacco held the position of superintendent while simultaneously serving as business administrator for several years.
"I don’t know how common that is around the state," Pisano said. But it allowed Ritacco to "single-handedly" put his plan into place, installing co-schemers into district contracts and given them district jobs.
"He had among other things the authority to select professional services providers including insurance brokers, and could recommend personnel," Pisano said. "It would not surprise me that he also had the authority that he single handedly chose these professionals."
Pisano continued: "Essentially Mr. Ritacco had complete control of the school district...There is no question that you abused that authority."
Pisano said that while superintendent Ritacco managed to install innovative programs. Ritacco's Attorney Jerome Ballaratto made Ritacco's successes as superintendent a large part of his presentation during sentencing, commending his client.
"Even while he’s committing this crime he’s doing good things for the school district," Ballaratto said.
However, Ritacco said he managed to create an environment where the school board and district "did anything I asked."
"The employees of our district, they did anything, anything I asked. I was superintendent, there wasn't one greivance, one arbitration," Ritacco said and later finished: "I accept responsibility for my actions."
Exit82
7:19 am on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
Tammi Millar, and anyone else hired by Mike Ritacco while he was stealing millions, should be fired today. And, any BOE member who has relatives hired by Ritacco should quit, now.
George
8:17 am on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
It's shameful that the board majority is trying to put a positive spin on the judge's statement -- to cover their "assets." They should never have made a "leap of faith" for that crook. They should resign, let diligent taxpayers replace them, and implement the reforms they rejected in recent months. Why are we paying their PR hack to be in court and write that crap? Enough is enough! We can't let this slide by.
disaronnodays
1:00 pm on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
Exit82: People should remember the politics of the situation here. It's no secret that most of these posts are from a small handful of people using 10 or more names. Let's hear what all you Democrats have to say as you watch what happens with your taxes. I'm not defending the Republicans. Both sides are disgusting. These board member positions are non-paid positions. Imagine Gilmore telling a person if they can run or not. Don't take that as a feather in your cap, you pitiful Democrats. You are equally repulsive with your own trickery.
KC
9:55 am on Thursday, October 4, 2012
Agree!
i don't get it??
8:07 am on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
I call B.S. on the Ritacco Board of Ed...they had to know what was going on...get them all out!!
KC
9:55 am on Thursday, October 4, 2012
And fumigate when they are gone!
George
8:22 am on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
The Ritacco 6 must go! Resign now, or face a landslide of embarrassment and perhaps investigations.
Ben
11:05 am on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
Six, I thought only two of his old members were up this year?
JD
8:23 am on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
The current BOE doesn't do the job they were voted in to do.
They rubber stamp everything. Committee meetings are a joke. 30 minutes long.
The board president himself recently said, he relies on the recommendations of the superindentant and did not know the details.
Well... isn't that how Ritacco got all that money through the insurance stuff... they relied upon his recommendations then. The BOE tries to say.... oh, but now we really look into the insurance stuff... yea but... what about the rest!!!
Are you hiring the best qualified people or just friends, family, etc... and maybe that is why test scores have trended downward for TRRS compared to other schools.
Do you really need all these staff positions? no
I can go on and on..
The BOE is the check and balance of the admin.... bottom line they have breached their fiduciary duty.
Why didn't Tammi Millar stand up saying she was there on behalf of the BOE??
She knew she would get a tongue lashing by the judge.
disaronnodays
11:52 am on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
JD: You said you were there. The judge was looking for a board member, not an employee. You appear to hate everyone associated with the schools no matter what position they hold. Were you scolded in school? Were you a bully? Sounds like your personal problems go back to your childhood.
barbara
8:44 am on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
Will people without "friends" now be able to work in the TR school system? Just ask around and see how many teachers, etc. can't get a job in Toms River because "you have to know somebody". Hope those days are over!
H.HEMMES
9:22 am on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
Teachers who were working before MJR and highly qualified for administration positions were passed over for a family or friend of the BOE or MJR. This created a situation where there was no incentive for advancement and apathetic attitudes prevailed.
disaronnodays
1:00 pm on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
barbara: Tell them to go to Brick, Central Regional, Lacey, Jackson, etc. Bet it's no different there either! Those days will never be over. Go to a TR board meeting and ask Gus if his personal list of people to be hired has been taken care of yet.
disaronnodays
2:25 pm on Tuesday, September 25, 2012
H.HEMMES: You were a teacher in the district. Were you passed over????
KC
9:55 am on Thursday, October 4, 2012
Barbara You are absolutely correct! It is pretty much common knowledge. Toms River is not the only district either. How can a union not keep an active out of work list for teachers? They have to be the only workplace allowed to hire in such an arbitrary, capricious and nepotistic fashion.
Shelly
8:46 am on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
If the Board of Ed can honestly say that they didn't know what Ritacco was up to, then they are more stupid than we think they are. They should all be booted out due to incompetence come on taxpayers....these are your hard earned tax dollars that are being wasted!!! Do not allow them to continue to destroy the Toms River reputation!
Walsh
9:06 am on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
You will have your chance to get rid of the remaining Ritacoo old board members. Two of them are running this November.
JD
10:53 am on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
There is a 3rd running in South Toms River... Jubert..
tuna stick
9:19 am on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
There are members of the BOE that called it right a long time ago, however, no wanted to listen to them.
There should be a house cleaning in the administration though. Either they knew what Ritacco was doing and looked the other way. Or they didn't know what he was doing, and for that matter, they don't belong in a postion like that.
There's only 2 things that should matter to the school administration: the school curriculum, and all that entails; and the cost of that to the taxpayer. Period. The end.
Not putting on concerts, and not speculating on real estate.
disaronnodays
1:00 pm on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
tuna stick: Speculating on real estate? They bought 1144 for $6 million and now own it outright. Today it's worth $18 million! Bravo, Ritacco. Frank R. and Bill D. would never have been able to pull that one off.
tuna stick
2:53 pm on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
then maybe he (they) should be in the real estate business. But not at the same time as being superintendent. Everything they do outside of the scope of their position is a distraction, and moreover, at a cost to the pupils. Once again, I will say that's there's only 2 things that should matter. And if making money thru real estate is your answer to my statement "cost to the taxpayer's", then I apologize for not being clear. The 2 things they should matter are the curriculum, and then the taxpayer. In that order.
KC
9:55 am on Thursday, October 4, 2012
Okay, Dis how are you related? It is apparent from your posts that you work for the school. Aren't you embarrassed by this? Who was your rabbi?
Seriously?
9:22 am on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
Never mind resigning -- every BOE member during Ritacco's reign should be in jail.
Let the new indictments begin!!!
butch cassidy
10:08 am on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
also i know mr roselli is a nice guy but he too was there during the cardone etc yrs..all buds with ritacco...should have hired someone from outside toms river to fill that position
Mac
10:37 am on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
Forget the BOE stooges. They couldn’t and can’t help themselves. They were born to be just what they are. BOEs, MUAs, local governments and all associated local committees, boards and commissions in Ocean County employ a small group of law firms for almost every legal action procured within our county’s borders. Most of these political inside law agencies are owned and staffed by elected and appointed state, county and local lawyers that bill us for millions of dollars each year (usually not itemized). If this small group of politically-connected law firms is so superior and skilled than all the other law practices available to us, why do they miss so much corruption over and over again that repeatedly takes place on their watch? After reading the comments over the past couple of years on the Patch, it’s clear the people have a pretty good handle on the what’s, why’s and whose of unsavory associations demeaning our standard of living. What I don’t understand is why our country no longer has law enforcement that can see the same shortcomings and respond accordingly?
disaronnodays
1:00 pm on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
Mac: Law enforcement is waiting for the directive to come down from the Governor!
Mac
2:53 pm on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
Oh, I understand the obstacles that encumber law enforcement. When the SCI was neutered by Whitman and Gluck, state investigations into political corruption came to an abrupt end in NJ, except for the occasional political vendetta. Imagine investigating a corrupt action and then having to ask your boss if it was okay to use the information obtained against him to indict and prosecute him. My thinking was more in line with a special federal prosecutor. I would think someone in the Department of Justice would be concerned how a sloppy investigation leading up to the Bid Rig II busts resulted in an outgoing and former federal prosecutor, and a large part of his inner-circle staff, ending up in possession of the executive branch of the state they had been successfully investigating for political corruption at top dollar.
KC
9:55 am on Thursday, October 4, 2012
Our fair governor only throws it at Interim Commissioners of Education!
Greg
1:00 pm on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
Many years ago prayer and God were taken from our children. We see, in general, how it has effected them and our society. It's all relative. <><
chtulu2000
2:53 pm on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
Oh please Greg...many years ago people were turning fire hoses on people in the streets, people lived in Hooverville, women couldn't get a divorce even if their husbands beat them, the list goes on...this has nothing to do with God or prayer.
KC
9:55 am on Thursday, October 4, 2012
Thank you chtulu. You said it for us.
Hector Logan
2:25 pm on Tuesday, September 25, 2012
If tammi were to resign/quit etc.. every person who works for Patch would have their resume on the superintendent's desk the day after. THere's a reason Patch is critical of Mrs. Millar. Did you ever notice patch never runs any positive stories about the toms river school district? Never reports the accomplishments of our children, their teachers.etc? They'd rather beat the ritacco horse all day long and be the new rag in town.
KC
9:55 am on Thursday, October 4, 2012
Nobody is trying to take away from the students or teachers. People are trying to piece
together the depth of this corruption. If you want feel-good stories I suggest you read the kill trees for coupons paper in your driveway.
BobD
1:00 pm on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
They should clean house at the TR BOE. I can't understand how no one questioned the logic, never mind the wisdom, of naming The Ritacco Center. Back then there should have been red flags and questions as to how any organization could name a facility under their control after a sitting President! What message did that send to anyone and everyone who worked in the TR School system? Who would be fool enough to speak up if they disagreed with Ritacco or questioned his actions or policies after that? He didn't name the center himself - one of his faithful minions had to suggest it and push it through some sort of approvals process. Who on Earth would vote against it and not be in fear of losing their job?
DennyD
1:00 pm on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
No one on the BOE realized that there is a "bidding" process that is law for public school districts? The only person that was aware of any illegal activity was Mr. Ritacco? Really? What were the spoils to be gained for people who vehmently campaigned for a spot on the BOE? Signs all over TR, radio commercials and glossy mailers. All that outlay for a "non-paying" position? You win, then you allow the Superintendent to do it all himself? WTF?
Tom Davis
1:14 pm on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
Everyone: Please be mindful that our Terms of Service prohibit posting unproven accusations or charges, or making any assumptions or claims that can't be proven. Repeated posts that do not comply to our Terms of Service could lead to suspension. Thanks very much.
clamdigger
2:53 pm on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
it's up to you Tom to do the research, that's what reporters do (or so I've heard), they hear something and follow up on it by actually doing some investigation, that's where the term Investagative Reporting came from.
What proof would you like? Signed documents,video? You signed up to be a reporter,it's time to dig in and get the bottom of stuff people are talking about.
If you want stuff spoon fed to you get a high chair and move back home w/ momma.
Dev
2:53 pm on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
Terms of service.... Ha! What a joke. That's one of the reasons why these criminals can fleece the taxpayers as openly as they do. If you "journalists" (I use the term loosly) would worry more about doing your job and less about terms of service they'd be less inclined to do it. You of all people should be defending ones rights to speak their minds, not stifling it. Don't know why I'm bothering. You'll probably delete this anyway.
clamdigger
6:21 am on Wednesday, September 19, 2012
it's another reason why people like to post using a nom de plume, they fear the possibility of retribution or just one of these people could possibly pointing in the right direction. It just might take someone w/ a knife (or a pen) to peel back the layers and see what there is to be found.
KC
9:55 am on Thursday, October 4, 2012
You are right on that clamdigger!
Pam Gethard
2:53 pm on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
my question refers to the last part of the article being discussed..... why did the employees of the district , not have a grievance or an arbitration situation ... was it trust or was it something else ? Did the employees do anything he asked because they trusted him ,feared him or were made a promise of something ?
JD
3:19 pm on Tuesday, September 18, 2012
No grievances... no arbs...
he is proud of that!!!
But look at those test scores go down, down, down the last 10 years..
TRRS use to be ranked in the 60th percentile of NJ... now it is in the 35th percentile.
TR Independent Thinker
6:21 am on Wednesday, September 19, 2012
You have to ask where was the teacher's union with not a single grievance or arbitration. Maybe that is because in exchange their family members or friends got jobs just like the BOE. When was the last time management and union never had grievances or disagreements. Only when they are on the same page. You figure it out. Teachers were told by their union who to vote for BOE, vote for the budget, and work Toms River Fest, etc.
KC
9:55 am on Thursday, October 4, 2012
JD and TR -
Right, and Right! Test scores go down in part because the district does not hire experienced teachers. They will only hire out of college newbies who are in the friends and family network. Now there is nothing inherently wrong with hiring out of college newbies, but they should not be the only pool from which you draw if you are to have experienced people who know what they are doing. It takes a good decade to learn the craft of pedagogy. What I am saying can easily be confirmed by examining the hiring records over the last three and a half decades of which I personally am aware. It would not take an act of Congress for someone to expedite.
KC
9:55 am on Thursday, October 4, 2012
It is not hard to imagine the evironment of fear and intimidation. That is how most of these bullies and their lackies reign supreme.
teatleytea
2:25 pm on Tuesday, September 25, 2012
I am going to try this one more time. The post that I had made earlier was in reference to "exit 82's" post that anyone who was hired while Ritacco was stealing money or was on the BOE while the same was going on the should resign. This person also stated that even if they have family an friends who were hired during that time frame they should also resign. And, the comment that I made was that I agreed with him/her and I also stated that if that were to happen there would be an awful lot of teachers missing from the classroom,bus drivers,board office workers,janitors, (I think you get my point) throughout the ENTIRE school system today. If you take a look at Data Universe on the APP you would see just what we are talking about with the names that you could play connect the dots with. From the Super on down. Then there was a comment made that if you looked into the school board you would see that there are only four members on the board that have NO connections to anyone in the district. But, then again one of the people would have to resign because he was on the board while this was going on so that would only leave the three members who were voted onto the board after Ritacco was arrested. Where is there any misinformation in this post Tom? If there is please enlighten me? Do you attend BOE meetings? If you do why did you not listen to what Galante, Lazaro,Kenett,Benson and Luthman had to say. Because from what I have read it seems to me that the judge proved them CORRECT!!
Leave it on the Field
6:21 am on Wednesday, September 19, 2012
I challenge everyone to Google "United States of America v Michael J. Riacco & Francis X. Gartland" to see the actual indictment & all the counts against them. When you do that, you'll realize that there are very few NJ BOE members 'qualified' to notice or root out the kind of criminal behavior that played out in Tom's River. Mr. Ritacco & his pals counted on that FACT. Now Google "Ritacco, Michael - Department of Justice - Honorable Garrett E. Brown v. : Crim No. 10-713 (GEB) Michael J. Ritacco" & read the 50 pgs in one sitting. Try to imagine all those fraudulant transactions existing while the BOE smiled or slept as millions of taxpayer dollars changed hands. After we're done being sick, all school districts should consider employing & paying a Big-4 Accounting Audit Team (KPMG, E&Y) rather than giant salaries and separation payouts to superintendents who can harm your entire district if they choose to. Ban them all from participating in vendor selection if you don't have a "legitimate process" that will root out whether or not they or BOE members & their family members are partners, stakeholders or silent benefactors in such firms. Do biz cautiously with firms that give you only a P.O. Box & go to the address tied to the PO. Execute random audits of vendor books, ops & bank accounts. Allow no subcontractors to support primary vendors unless all Fed IDs, corp backgrounds, D&B & credit histories have been thoroughly vetted & approved by qualified finance professionals.
KC
9:55 am on Thursday, October 4, 2012
Auditors, Oh my God what a concept! You are so right. That is an excellent idea - you need a forensic audit to clean this mess up. The corruption is rampant not only in TR but throughout the state. You have actually hit on a great idea. These sons o guns have been acting with impunity and dare I say arrogance. They need a little PWC in their life. Excellent point. Excellent.
Leave it on the Field
6:21 am on Wednesday, September 19, 2012
Also - Are you telling us the Tom's River Board of Ed actually released a statement that read in part, "What happened here was not a failure of the system, it was a failure of an individual and a violation of the trust imparted to him, both statutorily and in practice, by the very nature of his position?" You're kidding, right?! What Michael Ritacco did to your community and what your BOE failed to prevent represents a OBSCENE SYSTEMIC FAILURE inside your entire school system that was bolstered by the BOE's incompetence & lack of skills! No checks & balances, no vendor management, procurement, contracting, accounting, or audit processes to honor your fiduciary responsibilities to taxpayers & Tom's River's students. No transparency, lots of nepotism and outrageous failure by all of you who did not recommend & employ methods, tools, technologies and actions to prevent what happened. If I lived in your town, I'd ask you all to resign over the statements in today's Patch article alone. Employ an educated BOE spokesperson & stop embarrassing your community, our county & NJ.
ikidunot
9:52 pm on Wednesday, September 19, 2012
I've got news for you, Ms. Millar. The school board completely abdicated its responsiblity. In the end, as the long time mouth piece for this corrupt corporation, you're unbelievable.
Local
9:52 pm on Wednesday, September 19, 2012
The board is all elected correct? So it's easy fix next election right?
Dev
6:50 am on Thursday, September 20, 2012
These sheep love being robbed. How do you think this socialist education model got started. No one votes, no one that has half a brain or isn't in some way connected to the scam. And that's exactly how they want it. It's happening as I type this and always will. Well until the coffers empty which is only a matter of time. Call me a pessimist but I've learned to never underestimate the stupidity or greed of others.
Billy Squire
6:50 am on Thursday, September 20, 2012
This is what most BOE do in the schools. They give and hand their rights and public elected job directly over to the superintendents. The superintendents, Financial Advisors and Lawyers run the show. Just more BS excuses of the claims they don't or didn't know what was going on. They just look the other way more like it. The superintendent and BOE intentions start out good and quickly goes down hill with greed, special treatment and favors. You soon realize what is going on when you start finding out how or who these individuals no by either receiving their jobs, positions and or placement of jobs.
skizma
6:59 am on Thursday, September 20, 2012
Billy, unfortunately you are mostly right. I was a board member at our very small school and watched the click approve 4 grand to someone AFTER they wrote themselves out a check first. I caught it, pulled it out and said this is not approved. We can't give this money, it was never approved and the work should NEVER have been done without prior approval, especially by a contracted business administrator who KNEW the laws. The idiotic other board members put it to a vote and three said yes....viola, she/he got the check. Go find out what to do, no one helped. years later I find I should have go to the prosecutor. This business administrator finally retires and TAKES all proof of her/his actions home, out of the school. Damn crook. And laughs all the way. Now, the idiot board member who was the most "qualified" lol at that, is our town financial officer!!! We are all being taken by the louses and let me tell you - you are SUPPOSED to turn your head. These people think they are ENTITLED. the board members who said yes to the illegal taking of money from our school were then treated to lavish dinners and events from the money. BS at the highest level. From kids and OUR taxes. Not theirs. NOT ALL board members will do this, but you are out numbered. It sucks.
PPB1901
2:25 pm on Tuesday, September 25, 2012
skizma, If you read Billy's post again, he did not say All, He said Most... All the BOE members who allow this abuse to go on should end up in jail.. They are no better. I am sick of all these BOE that pretend they are for the students and tax payers. They are not, if they were they would never allow all this nonsense to go on. They are not even fair with the students with in the schools. They put themselves and their own a head of other students when they really don't deserve it.
KC
9:55 am on Thursday, October 4, 2012
And go into a classroom with nothing more than a piece of chalk. It is all abysmal. I think the town should take Leave It On the Field's advice and DEMAND an audit.
skizma
7:00 am on Thursday, September 20, 2012
would love to know if there is a statute of limitations on this type of lousy behavior.....anyone know?
KC
9:55 am on Thursday, October 4, 2012
Judge Pisano, this corruption is rampant throughout the State of New Jersey! Hiring practices alone are an issue that people have been outraged by for decades now. The governor won't touch this issue - the Commissioners of Education are always "Interim" The Superintendents as well. Who is in Charge? Someone needs to do a thorough and complete investigation of these cesspool Boards.
Frederick John LaVergne for Congress
5:31 am on Saturday, October 6, 2012
Corruption is always easy to find, folks - FOLLOW THE MONEY.